about my loss

Rayan · Joined: 06 Sep 2004 Posts: 98

I apologise for my harash words against M-L, although I still think some lower level judges are unfair and when u complain u get
* You were kicked from #Judges4you by some random judge* (bye)
Neo investigated the matter and I got the win(or more like the rating for the win), ofc I didnt care that much about he rating, what I wanted was the opportunity to go on playing in the trial, but the fact that in the end that mistake was fixed as much as it could makes me feel good, and also the fact that for once, I got what I wanted when I complained about judge's decision, instead of getting kicked/banned.

In the end I would like to ask all the judges, next time when a match outcome is influenced by some technical problems, let sportsmanship prevail over rules, because rules were made for NORMAL situations, when there is another factor(like missing timer), u should think as human beings that know what honor and sportsmanship is, not like machines that follow only rules.

Also I want to clarify for 2nd time, when I said I am not gonna send email to Koen/Nico, I am not doing that NOT because they are not gonna do sth about it(I didnt know NEO is the one who is responsible for RATING issues), BUT because I dont care that much about rating, as for the opportunity to play in the trial, and also making it public and seeing ppl agree with me is much more important to me than those 24 rating points(24 is the difference between losign or winning the match, like if I lose, I lose 11, if I win I win 13, 11+13=24), just as right now I am happy about the fact that Neo investigated and fixed this unfairness more about the fact that I got 24 rating points.

PS. I didnt put the name of the judge that kicked me, nor the name of the judge that ruled wrongly against me, so that this is not taken as a personal attack against those people, but as a message to all the judges.

EDIT: since he doesnt care, the judge who ruled against me is Blake-
<Blake-> idc if you mention me or not
<Blake-> I dont know you

Blake- · Posted: Mon Dec 04, 2006 9:06 pm Post subject:

I ruled from the information I was given 15 min. after the round ended when there were other judges present. I had no time, and had to make a decision, sorry it didn't go in your favor.

Rayan · Joined: 06 Sep 2004 Posts: 98

Said this in #judges4you and got kicked, said this in upper post, said this to u in PM, yet u seem to not understand it, I may be wrong, so I will ask any judge that happens to pass through this thread to tell me if this oppinion of mine is right or wrong:

When an M-L technical problem influences the outcome of a match, and players ask judges for a ruling, instead of blindly following the rules, judges should make the more sportsman ruling, because the rules were made for NORMAL situations, in extraordinary situations caused by M-L technical issues, judges need to show some sportsmanship and common sense, not only knowledge of rules.
Ofc I am not saying all judges are like that, and I must admit, that if I kept cool and didnt let emotions take over me, but concentrated and defended my point in the best way I am capable of, Blake- may have made the right ruling.

IAmSoDamSian · Joined: 07 Feb 2005 Posts: 26

This thread is sooooo getting locked. RUn the admins are coming!

Goji · Joined: 09 Apr 2006 Posts: 102

lol I so agree

Pete278 · Joined: 03 Jun 2005 Posts: 48

Following rules = tech.

Seriously, did you not read what Neo said? Don't post another thread on this, or you'll get a warning and this'll be locked.