CaC 103 Judged

Stucco · Joined: 14 Mar 2005 Posts: 902

The winner is BlackPen.
The runner-up is CMA-Flippi.

Judgings can be found here.

Concerns can be voiced, but judgings are final. Twenty-five cards to analyze in one sitting (since we like rapid-fire rounds) is a bit taxing, there will be more rounds after this.

CMA-Flippi · Posted: Mon Apr 02, 2012 11:18 am Post subject:

My card shouldve lost 1 point on functionality. WotC doesnt like printing 2 cards with the same flavortext Razz

See
[url]http://magiccards.info/scans/en/us/8.jpg
[/url]

At the same time, I feel the category balance refers to cards like Bloodbraid elf or Geist of Saint Traft as too strong and good old Chimney Imp as too bad. On that one, my image of how MtG should be is probably outdated however.

Stucco · Joined: 14 Mar 2005 Posts: 902

Hah, damn, I checked the flavor text of all of the 'Voice of' cards and figured you read poetry on the side. Razz

About balance, I agree with you about Geist and Bloodbraid, however the balance category that I stole from the previous judge was 10 pts. That leaves quite a bit of room for interpretation. If I changed anything about the rubric, I'd combine Balance and Functionality, and maybe make a 'printability + creativity' section.

poolsclosed · Joined: 10 Jul 2007 Posts: 7

CMA-Flippi · Posted: Mon Apr 02, 2012 3:09 pm Post subject:

BLADE will also not enter Innistrad Razz

poolsclosed · Joined: 10 Jul 2007 Posts: 7

Canabiest · Joined: 15 Aug 2006 Posts: 158

Well my card was more supposed for block constructed Wink

I want to see allied duals in Avacyn Restored.

blitzer2k7's Avacyn, Archangel destorys herself as worded Wink

NearSideMoon · Joined: 29 Mar 2012 Posts: 52

Thanks for the compliments on your review. I knew balance would be an issue, guess I wasn't thinking about Block.

If I were to change anything, it would probably be having it cost either BBB and 1 or 'Grixis' and 1 (White and Green's enemy colors.)

Stucco · Joined: 14 Mar 2005 Posts: 902