Worst Band Ever Round 1

Bushviper · Joined: 07 Aug 2006 Posts: 82

Okay! The people have spoken and we have a nomination list for the worst bands ever chosen by your fellow m-l members.

If you don’t know what this is about, click the link below:
http://www.magic-league.com/phpBB/about6713.html

Here are the groups divided by decade of formation (I decided to do this because everyone would argue over what genre to put certain bands in, this is more clear cut).

Group A
1950-1979
• The Bee Gees
• Blue Oyster Cult
• Led Zeppelin
• Pink Floyd
• The Beatles
• The Temptations
• The Rolling Stones

Group B
1980-1989
• Nirvana
• Red Hot Chili Peppers
• Aqua
• Insane Clown Posse
• Meat Puppet
• Mettalica

Group C
1990-1999
• Creed
• Hansen
• Flogging Molly
• Dropkick Murphys
• Simple Plan
• Lamb of God
• Avenged Seven Fold
• Limp Bizkit
• All American Rejects
• New Found Glory
• Disturbed
• Hoobastank
• Sevendust
• Nickleback
• Kottonmouth King
• Good Charlotte
• Puddle of Mud
• Eiffel 65
• Bowling for Soup
• Crossfade
• System of a Down
• Rage Against the Machine
• Mushroom Head
• Slipknot
• Linkin Park

Group D
2000- Present
• Tokyo Hotel
• Fall Out Boy
• The Used
• Panic at the Disco
• Click Five
• My Chemical Romance

Now, through random pairing as the result of alotttttttttt of dice rolling, we have our first round:

Round 1

Group A
1. The Temptations vs. The Rolling Stones
2. Pink Floyd vs. The Bee Gees
3. The Beatles vs. Blue Oyster Cult
4. Led Zeppelin vs. Bye

Group B
5. Aqua vs. Red Hot Chili Peppers
6. Meat Puppet vs. Mettalica
7. Nirvana vs. Insane Clown Posse

Group C
8. All American Rejects vs. Eiffel 65
9. Bowling for Soup vs. Crossfade
10. Kottonmouth King vs. Hoobastank
11. Mushroom Head vs. Sevendust
12. Simple Plan vs. Flogging Molly
13. New Found Glory vs. Lamb of God
14. System of a Down vs. Disturbed
15. Puddle of Mud vs. Nickleback
16. Avenged Seven Fold vs. Hansen
17. Dropkick Murphys vs. Limp Bizkit
18. Creed vs. Slipknot
19. Good Charlotte vs. Linkin Park
20. Rage Against the Machine vs. Bye

Group D
21. Tokyo Hotel vs. Click Five
22. My Chemical Romance vs. Fallout Boy
23. The Used vs. Panic at the Disco

Now, to demonstrate how this will work, I will give you an example. Notice the numbers next to all the matchups. Submit your answers like this:

1. The Temptations
2. The Bee Gees
3. The Beatles
4. Led Zeppelin
5. Eiffel 65
6. Aqua
7. Insane Clown Posse
8. Eiffel 65
9. Crossfade
10. Hoobastank
11. Sevendust
12. Simple Plan
13. New Found Glory
14. System of a Down (That was a hard decision)
15. Puddle of Mud
16. Hansen
17. Limp Bizkit
18. Slipknot
19. Good Charlotte
20. Rage Against the Machine
21. Click Five
22. Fallout Boy
23. Panic a the Disco

Here are my results. Again, please note you are voting for the WORST band so put down the band you dislike more in your results.

I’ll let this go for a day or two and then we will start Round 2.

Happy Voting!

cjthedude · Joined: 29 Jan 2005 Posts: 98

how bored with your life can you be to do this?

Engrishskill · Joined: 15 Jan 2007 Posts: 249

Nickleback fucking blows.

Memo · Joined: 27 Sep 2004 Posts: 5

1. The Temptations
2. Bee Gees
3. Blue Oyster Cult
4. Led Zeppelin (bye definitely destroys them)
5. Aqua
6. Meat Puppet
7. Nirvana
8. Eiffel 65 (i'm NOT proud they're italians)
9. Bowling for Soup
10. Hoobastank
11. Mushroom Head
12. Simple Plan
13. New Found Glory (LoG rule)
14. SoaD
15. both (i have to choose one so i'll go for Nickelback but they both suck hard)
16. Hansen
17. Limp Bizkit
18. Creed
19. Linkin Park (but Good Charlotte sucks as much)
21. Tokyo Hotel
22. My Chemical Romance
23. Panic at the Disco

how bored of my life can i be to answer to this?

KeySam · Joined: 14 Oct 2005 Posts: 322

who the hell sayed pink floyd is worst band???
i realy dont know what to say.

yavin1 · Joined: 15 Jul 2006 Posts: 144

1. temptations
2 bee gees
3blue oyster cult
4 bye (zeppelin is too good)
5 aqua
6 meat puppet
7 insane clown posse
8. eiffel 65
9 crossfade
10 hoobastank
11. seven dust
12 simple plan
13. hmmm. both? lamb of god probably
14. disturbed
15. nickleback
16 avenged seven fold
17. limp kizkit
18 tough again...slipknot
19 good charlotte
20 bye. rage is good
21 tokyo hotel
22 fallout boy
23 panic at the disco

Fanboy · Joined: 16 Jun 2005 Posts: 399

Ill agree most of these bands deserve to be on this list...and their often mentioned more than once in the prior thread to this. But some of these bands REALLY REALLY shouldn't be in this list EVER.

But i'll play ball...

A.
1. Temptations (they do their sound well...but Rolling stones kicks ass)
2. Bee Gees (Pink Floyd is actually good...and al so hate the Bee Gees)
3. ???? (whos blue oyster cult?)
4. bye

B
5. Aqua (Another issue where one band is really good and the other is an atrocity)
6. ????? (dunno who meat puppet is...)
7. Insane Clown Posse (see answer 5)

C
8. Eiffel 65
9. Crossfade (both suck sooooo hard)
10. Kottonmouth Kings (pot head rap FTL)
11. ????? (dunno either)
12. Simple Plan (I actually like Flogging Molly)
13. ????? (dunno Lamb of God)
14. System of a Down (They have their moments...and then the album after Toxicity came out...)
15. Nickleback (Holy fuck that decision was hard!)
16. Limp Bizkit (lol sooo fuckin white trash...)
17. Creed (Slipknot is pretty neutral with me)
18. Good Charlotte (linkin parks not too bad...it's mostly their fan base that sucks royal)
19. Bye (I loves the RAGE!)

D
21. ????? (who the fuck are they?)
22. Fall Out Boy (another VERY hard choice)
23. Panic at the Disco (see above)

Oedipus · Joined: 26 Nov 2006 Posts: 88

Who the fuck says Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin and The Rolling Stones and the Beatles are bad!? I personally don't like the Beatles or the Rolling Stones, but they are still very good. Pink Floyd is the greatest band ever! Hands down.

Lewdbox · Joined: 27 Apr 2007 Posts: 1

Group A
1. The Rolling Stones
2. The Bee Gees
3. Blue Oyster Cult
4. Bye

Group B
5. Aqua
6. Mettalica
7. Insane Clown Posse

Group C
8. All American Rejects
9. Bowling for Soup
10. Hoobastank
11. Sevendust
12. Simple Plan
13. New Found Glory
14. Disturbed
15. Nickleback
16. Avenged Seven Fold
17. Limp Bizkit
18. Creed
19. Good Charlotte
20. Bye

Group D
21. Click Five
22. Fallout Boy
23. Panic at the Disco

TofuBoy · Joined: 07 Oct 2005 Posts: 126

1-23. Nickelback.
They're so bad that there is no point in having different matchups. And yes, this was a partially serious answer. But, if you'd like me to do this properly here it goes:
1. Temptations
2. Bee Gees
3. BOC
4. Bye
5. Aqua
6. Meat Puppet
7. ICP
8. Eiffel 65
9. Crossfade
10. Hoobastank
11. Mushroom Head
12. Siple Plan
13. New Found Glory (Just finished playing LoG on Guitar Hero)
14. SoaD
15. Nickelback
16. Hanson
17. Limp Bizkit
18. Creed
19. Good Charlotte
20. Bye
21. Tokyo Hotel
22. FoB
23. Panic

Thorns · Joined: 16 Aug 2006 Posts: 566 Location: Rath

Group A
1. The Temptations [Stones own]
2. The Bee Gees [You can't even compare to Pink Floyd]
3. Blue Oyster Cult [I actually prefer BOC over The Beatles, but it's a really hard choice]
4. Bye [Hands down]

Group B
5. Aqua
6. Meat Puppet [HAHA funny]
7. Insane Clown Posse [UHM HELLO?!]

Group C
8. All American Rejects
9. Bowling for Soup [whatever]
10. Kottonmouth King
11. Mushroom Head
12. Simple Plan [they'll probably win this competition]
13. New Found Glory
14. System of a Down [this one actually makes sense]
15. Nickleback [they deserve to win too]
16. Avenged Seven Fold
17. Limp Bizkit
18. Slipknot
19. Linkin Park [So hard, no really, they both blow majorly]
20. Bye [RATM is sick!]

Group D
21. Tokyo Hotel [whatever]
22. Fallout Boy [MCR is remotely good]
23. Panic at the Disco [emo FTW!]

PorkyP · Joined: 07 Jan 2007 Posts: 14

1. The Temptations
2. Bee Gees
3. The Beatles (GO GO GODZILLA!!!)
4. bye

5. Aqua
6. Meat Puppet
7. ICP

8. Eiffel 65
9. Crossfade
10. Kottonmouth King
11. Mushroom Head (that was a tough one)
12. Simple Plan
13. New Found Glory (waaay too easy)
14. System of a Down (another tough one)
15. Puddle of Mud
16. Hansen (could this be the winner??)
17. Dropkick Murphy's
18. Creed (can't believe Slipknot is even on here)
19. Good Charolette
20. (WTF Rage does NOT belong on this list)

21. Hotel Tokyo (never heard of either)
22. My Chemical Romance
23. The Used

Atreyu24 · Joined: 23 Aug 2005 Posts: 31 Location: New York

First off, i must say there are some very good bands on here, like rage, pink floyd and blue oyster cult, and all of group d are terrible, but here are my votes:

1 the temptations
2 the bee gees
3 the beatles (tough one)
4 led zeppelin
5 aqua
6 mettalica
7 nirvana
8 all american rejects (don't know eiffel)
9 bowling for soup
10 kottonmouth
11 mushroomhead (also tough)
12 simple plan
13 new found glory
14 disturbed
15 puddle of mud
16 hansen
17 limp bizket
18 creed
19 good charlotte
20 rage (shouldn't be on here
21 click five
22 fallout boy (both are awful)
23 Used (see above)

Magx · Joined: 07 Sep 2004 Posts: 323

Round 1

Group A
1. The Temptations
2. The Bee Gees
3. Blue Oyster Cult
4. Led Zeppelin vs. Bye

Group B
5. Aqua vs.
6. Mettalica
7. Nirvana

Group C
8. All American Rejects
9. Bowling for Soup vs. Crossfade
10. Kottonmouth King
11. Mushroom Head
12. Floggin Molly
13. New Found Glory
14. System of a Down vs Disturbec (it's like to ask me too choose between my mother and my girflriend)
15. Puddle of Mud
16. Hansen
17. Dropkick Murphys
18. Creed
19. Good Charlotte
20. Rage Against the Machine vs. Bye

Group D
21. Tokyo Hotel
22. My Chemical Romance
23. Panic at the Disco

Fanboy · Joined: 16 Jun 2005 Posts: 399

How the hell did Nirvana get chosen people? Not too mention when its competing against ICP...

I mean jesus...do you know how hard it is to find something worse than ICP?!?